Have A Question? Search This Site:
Understanding Missouri DWI Arrests Without Breath Test Failure
Most people associate DWI (Driving While Intoxicated) arrests in Missouri with failing a breath test. It’s a common assumption: if your Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) doesn’t reach the legal limit of 0.08%, you’re safe from arrest. However, Missouri law allows for DWI arrests even if a driver does not fail a breath test—or even if they refuse to take one altogether.
The key concept here is impairment, not just BAC. Missouri law states that a person commits the offense of DWI if they are in an intoxicated or drugged condition while operating a motor vehicle. This means that if an officer observes clear signs of impairment, they can legally make an arrest even if a breath test is unavailable or shows a BAC under the legal threshold.
For example, a driver might exhibit erratic behavior, fail field sobriety tests, slur their speech, or be visibly impaired by drugs or a combination of substances. In such cases, the arrest is based on probable cause, not a specific chemical reading.
Missouri’s DWI laws are structured to prioritize road safety and give law enforcement discretion when determining whether someone is unfit to drive. Breath test results are just one of many tools used in this process. Understanding how these laws work can help clarify the difference between “passing” a test and avoiding arrest—because in Missouri, they’re not the same thing.
What Missouri Law Says About Impairment
Missouri’s legal definition of DWI is broader than just having a BAC of 0.08% or higher. According to state statutes, a person is considered to be driving while intoxicated if they are operating a vehicle in an intoxicated or drugged condition. This phrasing covers alcohol, drugs (both legal and illegal), and even combinations of substances that affect a person’s ability to drive safely.
The law allows officers to use behavioral evidence to determine impairment. If a driver is swerving, driving aggressively, showing confusion, or struggling to follow instructions, these may all serve as indicators—even without a high BAC.
Additionally, drug impairment often cannot be detected by a standard breathalyzer. In these situations, officers rely on field sobriety tests, observations, and sometimes a blood or urine test taken after arrest. If a driver is under the influence of marijuana, prescription medication, or illegal drugs, their BAC may be 0.00%, yet they can still be arrested and charged with DWI.
This flexible standard reflects Missouri’s emphasis on safe driving rather than numerical thresholds alone. While breath test results can strengthen a case, they are not a required element for a DWI charge to be filed.
Refusing a Breath Test Doesn’t Prevent Arrest
Many drivers believe that refusing a breath test will help them avoid arrest or legal trouble. In Missouri, that’s not the case. The state operates under implied consent laws, which means that by driving on public roads, you automatically agree to submit to chemical testing if an officer has reasonable grounds to suspect impairment.
Refusing a breath test triggers automatic license suspension—even if no DWI conviction occurs. More importantly, refusal does not stop an arrest from happening. If the officer already has enough probable cause based on the driver’s behavior or other evidence, they can proceed with an arrest without a breath test result.
In fact, refusal may be used as a factor that supports the arrest. Courts can view refusal as an indication that the driver was trying to avoid detection of intoxication, especially if other signs of impairment were present.
Missouri courts have consistently upheld DWI arrests in cases where no breath test was taken. Arrests are based on the totality of the evidence, not just a single number from a testing device.
Field Sobriety Tests and Observable Behavior
If a breath test isn’t used or doesn’t indicate impairment, Missouri officers turn to other tools—especially field sobriety tests and physical observations. These include:
- Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) Test: Observes involuntary eye movement as the driver follows a moving object
- Walk-and-Turn Test: Measures balance, coordination, and the ability to follow instructions
- One-Leg Stand: Assesses balance and timing while standing on one foot
If a driver fails one or more of these tests, it gives the officer probable cause to proceed with a DWI arrest—even in the absence of a failed breath test. These tests are designed to expose the subtle impairments caused by alcohol or drugs.
Additionally, officers may note other factors:
- Slurred speech
- Red or glassy eyes
- Odor of alcohol or drugs
- Inability to focus or respond clearly
- Difficulty exiting the vehicle or walking
All of these observations are documented and can be used to support an arrest decision. Missouri law gives officers discretion to interpret these signs based on their training and experience, especially when chemical tests are not available or inconclusive.
Drug-Related DWIs Without a BAC Reading
In cases involving drug impairment, breath tests often play no role at all. This is because most breathalyzers are designed to detect alcohol, not drugs. If a driver is suspected of being under the influence of marijuana, prescription sedatives, stimulants, or other substances, their breath test may show 0.00% BAC—but they can still be arrested for DWI.
Missouri officers rely on visual indicators, behavior, and sometimes drug recognition experts (DREs) to assess impairment. In certain situations, they may request a blood or urine test to detect the presence of drugs. These tests are usually conducted after the arrest and can serve as additional evidence.
Drug-related DWIs can be particularly complex because the presence of a substance does not always equate to impairment. However, if the officer observes behavior that indicates the driver is not in full control of their faculties, and there is confirmation of drug use, that’s often enough to justify a charge.
So while breath tests are commonly used in alcohol-related stops, they are not the deciding factor in drug-related DWI cases. Drivers should be aware that Missouri’s DWI laws encompass all forms of impairment, regardless of how they’re detected.
Probable Cause: The Legal Standard for Arrest
In Missouri, the threshold for making a DWI arrest is probable cause. This legal concept means that the officer has a reasonable belief, based on facts and observations, that a driver is operating a vehicle while impaired.
Probable cause can be based on any combination of the following:
- Poor performance on field sobriety tests
- Inconsistent or irrational responses during questioning
- Physical signs of intoxication
- Admission of alcohol or drug use
- Open containers or drug paraphernalia in the vehicle
- Slurred speech or confusion
If these elements are present, even without a failed breath test, Missouri law supports the officer’s authority to make an arrest. Courts look at the totality of the circumstances, not just test results.
The arrest process then continues with chemical testing (if consented to), booking, and potential charges. Whether or not a conviction follows depends on the strength of the evidence and how the case proceeds through the legal system—but the arrest itself only requires that probable cause be met.
Myths and Misconceptions About DWI Arrests in Missouri
Because of the strong association between BAC numbers and drunk driving, many myths persist about DWI arrests in Missouri. Here are a few of the most common misconceptions—and the truth behind them:
- Myth: “If I pass a breath test, I can’t be arrested.”
Fact: Officers can arrest based on behavior, even if BAC is under 0.08%. - Myth: “Refusing a breath test means I won’t be charged.”
Fact: Refusal leads to license suspension and may still result in arrest. - Myth: “You need to be visibly drunk to be charged.”
Fact: Subtle signs of impairment are enough for probable cause. - Myth: “Prescription medications are safe to drive on.”
Fact: Many prescriptions can impair driving, and DWI laws apply to legal drugs. - Myth: “There’s no point in cooperating if I’ve been drinking.”
Fact: Cooperation may affect the outcome of your case, but it won’t prevent arrest if signs of impairment exist.
Understanding these misconceptions can help drivers in Missouri avoid actions based on false assumptions. The state’s DWI laws are designed to prioritize safety and allow officers the discretion to act when someone appears impaired—regardless of breath test results.
FAQ About DWI Arrests Without Failing a Breath Test in Missouri
Can I be arrested for DWI if my BAC is below 0.08%?
Yes. Missouri law allows for arrest based on signs of impairment, even if BAC is below the legal limit.
Is refusing a breath test a way to avoid charges?
No. Refusal results in automatic license suspension and does not prevent arrest if other evidence supports impairment.
What other evidence can be used besides a breath test?
Field sobriety tests, physical behavior, driver statements, and observations made by the officer can all support an arrest.
Do drug-related DWI arrests require a breath test?
No. Breath tests don’t detect drugs. Officers may use observations or request blood or urine testing instead.
Can a DWI arrest happen without any chemical test?
Yes. Arrests can be made based on probable cause. Chemical testing typically happens after arrest.
Is a DWI arrest the same as a conviction?
No. An arrest starts the legal process. A conviction requires evidence and may depend on court outcomes.
Are field sobriety tests mandatory in Missouri?
No. Drivers can refuse, but officers may still arrest if other signs of impairment exist.
Conclusion
A failed breath test is not the only path to a DWI arrest in Missouri. Officers rely on a range of observations, field sobriety tests, and legal standards like probable cause to assess whether a driver is impaired.
Even without a high BAC—or any BAC at all—a driver may still face arrest and legal consequences. To learn more about the legal foundation behind these arrests, see our full guide on how DUI laws work. For more insight into how DWI arrests begin, check out what triggers a DUI arrest during a traffic stop.