Have A Question? Search This Site:
A DWI (Driving While Intoxicated) charge in Arkansas may feel like a final and irreversible outcome, but it is not uncommon for people to ask whether such charges can ever be dropped. The short answer is yes—DWI charges can be dropped under certain circumstances, but this is relatively rare and depends on multiple factors. From how the arrest was handled to the strength of the evidence, several elements can influence whether prosecutors decide to proceed with or dismiss a case.
In Arkansas, DWI cases are prosecuted based on either a driver’s BAC (blood alcohol concentration) being above the legal limit or on observed signs of impairment. Because of this dual structure, prosecutors often rely on both test results and officer testimony. If a significant problem arises with either of those sources of evidence, the case may be weakened to the point where dismissal becomes an option.
However, it’s important to understand that DWI charges are not dropped simply because a person has no prior offenses or cooperated during the arrest. Arkansas treats impaired driving seriously, and the law gives prosecutors broad authority to pursue charges. Still, certain procedural, evidentiary, or constitutional issues may lead to a charge being dismissed, reduced, or not filed at all.
This article explores the conditions under which DWI charges in Arkansas may be dropped, how the decision is made, and what typically needs to happen for a case to end without a conviction.
Understanding How DWI Charges Are Filed in Arkansas
DWI charges in Arkansas begin with an arrest and are followed by a review from the prosecuting attorney. The officer’s report, chemical test results, field sobriety test performance, and other observations are submitted to the local prosecutor for case evaluation.
At this stage, prosecutors decide whether to file formal charges based on:
- The strength of the evidence
- Whether probable cause existed for the arrest
- The results of chemical or breath tests
- Observations made by the arresting officer
If the prosecutor finds that the evidence meets the threshold for probable cause, a criminal charge is filed and a court date is scheduled. However, if there are problems with the arrest process or missing evidence, the case may be flagged for review, delay, or dismissal.
While officers initiate arrests, only the prosecuting attorney has the authority to formally file or drop charges. This means that even if an officer recommends proceeding, the prosecutor may decline to file if there are legal concerns.
Reasons DWI Charges Might Be Dropped
There are a limited number of circumstances in which DWI charges in Arkansas may be dropped. These generally fall into a few main categories:
1. Insufficient Evidence
If the prosecutor determines that there is not enough reliable evidence to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt, they may choose to dismiss the charge. This might happen if:
- The BAC test results are unavailable or inconclusive
- Field sobriety test results are missing or poorly documented
- Key witnesses (such as the arresting officer) are unavailable
2. Procedural Errors
If the officer did not follow proper procedures during the arrest or testing process, it may undermine the validity of the case. Examples include:
- Improper administration of field sobriety tests
- No clear probable cause for the traffic stop
- Mishandling of evidence
3. Violation of Rights
If the driver’s constitutional rights were violated—such as an unlawful search, lack of Miranda warnings, or denial of access to counsel—evidence may be excluded, which can result in the case being dropped.
4. Test Refusal Without Additional Evidence
If a driver refused chemical testing and there are no clear signs of impairment beyond that refusal, it may be difficult for the prosecution to proceed without supporting evidence.
In all of these cases, it’s not automatic that charges are dropped, but the situation may lead to further review or negotiations.
What Happens When Charges Are Dropped
If a DWI charge is dropped in Arkansas, it typically happens before the case reaches trial. This can occur:
- Before arraignment (formal charging hearing)
- After initial hearings, when evidence is reviewed
- During pretrial negotiations, where weaknesses are identified
When charges are dropped, the case is closed and no conviction appears on the individual’s criminal record for that offense. However, the arrest record may still exist, which can affect employment or background checks unless it is later sealed or expunged.
In some cases, charges are not fully dropped but may be reduced to a lesser offense such as reckless driving. This is more common in cases where the evidence is borderline or the prosecutor sees a benefit in resolving the case without trial.
It’s also possible for the prosecutor to drop one DWI-related charge while proceeding with another. For example, a drug-based impairment charge may be dropped while an alcohol-based charge moves forward, or vice versa.
The Role of Plea Bargains and Charge Reductions
Sometimes, a DWI charge is not dropped entirely but is negotiated into a plea deal for a lesser offense. This is often seen as a practical resolution when:
- The prosecution has concerns about the strength of the case
- The defense raises valid challenges to the evidence
- The driver has no prior DWI history
Possible outcomes of a plea deal might include:
- Pleading to reckless driving
- Pleading to a traffic violation with alcohol education conditions
- Avoiding jail time in exchange for treatment or community service
Arkansas law does not require prosecutors to offer plea deals, and plea agreements involving DWI charges are generally case-specific. The possibility of a reduced charge depends heavily on the details of the incident and the judgment of the prosecuting attorney.
Even in plea deal situations, the original DWI charge will still appear in the records, but the final outcome will reflect the agreed-upon reduced charge.
Challenges in Getting a DWI Charge Dropped
While it is legally possible for DWI charges to be dropped, it is not easy. Arkansas prosecutors are often reluctant to dismiss these cases without compelling justification. Impaired driving is a public safety issue, and the law is structured to prioritize enforcement.
Common challenges include:
- Strong test results (BAC over 0.08%)
- Clear signs of impairment documented by the officer
- Prior DWI offenses on the driver’s record
- Accidents or injuries involved in the incident
In these situations, prosecutors are more likely to move forward with charges, and courts are less likely to consider diversion programs or dismissals.
The decision to drop a charge is based on legal standards, not personal appeal or negotiation alone. Unless there is a significant flaw in the case, the prosecution will usually proceed.
Difference Between Dropped Charges and Dismissed Cases
Although the terms are often used interchangeably, “dropped charges” and “dismissed cases” refer to slightly different legal outcomes in Arkansas.
- Dropped charges usually occur before charges are formally filed or soon after initial review.
- Dismissed cases occur after charges have been filed, often due to a court ruling or agreement between the parties.
In both situations, the case does not proceed to conviction, but the timing and procedural steps differ. Dismissed cases may involve a court record showing the dismissal, while dropped charges may not result in a court case at all.
FAQ Section
Can a DWI Charge Be Dropped in Arkansas?
Yes. A DWI charge can be dropped if there is insufficient evidence, procedural errors, or constitutional violations during the arrest or investigation.
Who Decides Whether to Drop a DWI Charge?
The decision is made by the prosecuting attorney, not the arresting officer or the defendant.
Will a Dropped DWI Charge Appear on My Record?
The arrest may still appear on background checks, even if the charge is dropped. Expungement may be required to remove it completely.
Can a DWI Be Reduced to a Lesser Charge?
Yes. In some cases, a DWI may be reduced to a lesser charge like reckless driving through plea negotiations.
Do You Have to Go to Court if Charges Are Dropped?
If charges are dropped early, a court appearance may not be required. If they’re dropped later in the process, a court hearing may still take place.
Is It Common for DWI Charges to Be Dropped?
No. DWI charges are typically pursued unless there are major issues with evidence or procedure.
Conclusion
DWI charges in Arkansas can be dropped, but doing so typically requires specific circumstances such as weak evidence, procedural errors, or legal violations during the arrest. While the law allows room for dismissal or reduction, prosecutors are generally inclined to pursue these cases unless a clear issue undermines the strength of the case.
Understanding the distinction between dropped and dismissed charges, the prosecutor’s role, and how plea agreements function can help clarify what options may exist. Every case is different, and outcomes depend heavily on the facts presented.
For a detailed breakdown of the overall legal structure, visit How DUI Laws Work. To explore how charges are reviewed and prosecuted in Arkansas, see How DUI Charges Are Filed and Prosecuted.