Have A Question? Search This Site:
In Massachusetts, most drivers know the legal Blood Alcohol Content (BAC) limit for driving is 0.08%. But what many don’t realize is that you can be arrested and charged with OUI (Operating Under the Influence) even if your BAC is below that legal threshold.
The law in Massachusetts focuses not only on how much alcohol you have consumed, but more importantly on whether your ability to drive safely is impaired. A BAC reading is just one piece of the puzzle. If law enforcement officers observe behavior consistent with impairment—slurred speech, poor coordination, erratic driving—you can be charged with OUI regardless of what a breathalyzer says.
This article explores how and why Massachusetts law allows for OUI charges below the legal limit, how police assess impairment, what evidence can support a conviction, and how drivers—even those trying to “play it safe”—can still end up facing serious legal and administrative consequences.
What the Law Actually Says About BAC and OUI
Under Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 90, Section 24, it is illegal to operate a motor vehicle:
“While under the influence of intoxicating liquor, or of marijuana, narcotic drugs, depressants or stimulant substances… to such a degree that the person’s ability to operate the vehicle safely is impaired.”
Nowhere does the law state that your BAC must be 0.08% or higher. Instead, the statute focuses on impairment, not the number. A BAC of 0.08% or above creates a presumption of impairment under the law, but you can still be found guilty with a lower BAC if there’s other evidence showing you weren’t safe to drive.
In short: Massachusetts law allows OUI charges based on observed behavior and other non-chemical evidence.
How Drivers Are Charged with OUI Below 0.08%
So how exactly can someone be charged with OUI if they “pass” a breath test? The key is that a BAC reading is not the only indicator of impairment.
Here are the most common factors that can lead to a sub-0.08% OUI arrest:
1. Field Sobriety Test Performance
Police use Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (SFSTs) to assess coordination, balance, attention, and divided attention—skills critical to safe driving. These tests include:
- Walk-and-turn test
- One-leg stand test
- Horizontal gaze nystagmus test
Failing one or more of these tests—even with a BAC below 0.08%—can support an OUI charge if the officer believes you are too impaired to drive safely.
2. Driving Behavior and Officer Observations
Police reports often include detailed observations, such as:
- Weaving or drifting between lanes
- Braking inconsistently
- Running red lights or stop signs
- Delayed response to traffic signals
Other cues officers may document include:
- Slurred or slow speech
- Bloodshot, watery eyes
- Odor of alcohol
- Confused or agitated behavior
These observations carry significant weight in court and may be used to establish impairment—even in the absence of high BAC readings.
3. Admissions or Statements
A driver who says “I only had two drinks” or admits to using marijuana or medication may unintentionally strengthen the officer’s case. Any statements about alcohol or drug use can be noted in the arrest report and used as evidence.
Even if your BAC is below 0.08%, self-incriminating remarks can contribute to an OUI charge.
4. Combining Substances
Alcohol isn’t the only substance that can cause impairment. Massachusetts OUI law includes:
- Prescription drugs
- Marijuana
- Narcotics
- Inhalants (like glue or aerosol sprays)
If an officer suspects that a combination of alcohol and other substances is impairing your ability to drive, a low BAC reading won’t necessarily help your case. You can still be charged if your overall behavior indicates you’re not safe behind the wheel.
Massachusetts Legal Limits by Driver Type
Different drivers are subject to different BAC thresholds under Massachusetts law:
- Drivers age 21 and over: 0.08%
- Commercial vehicle drivers: 0.04%
- Drivers under 21: 0.02%
These lower limits mean that many drivers face legal consequences even when they’re well below the standard 0.08% limit.
Example:
An underage driver stopped with a BAC of 0.03% is above the legal limit for their age group. That driver may face administrative penalties, license suspension, and even criminal charges.
Similarly, a commercial driver operating a semi-truck with a BAC of 0.05% is over the legal limit for their license type and can be disqualified from holding a commercial driver’s license.
The Role of the “Per Se” Rule vs. Actual Impairment
Massachusetts operates under both a “per se” rule and an “actual impairment” rule.
- Per Se Rule: A BAC of 0.08% or more = legally presumed impaired.
- Actual Impairment Rule: A person is impaired if alcohol or drugs have negatively impacted their ability to drive safely—even if BAC is under 0.08%.
This dual system allows officers and prosecutors to pursue OUI charges in cases where the BAC is not elevated, but the behavior clearly indicates a lack of control or coordination.
This is especially important in cases involving:
- Tired or sick drivers who consume small amounts of alcohol
- Mixed use of alcohol and prescription medication
- Drivers with low tolerance who become impaired at lower BACs
There’s no requirement that BAC must be high—only that the driver is unable to operate safely.
Refusing a Breath or Blood Test Still Results in Penalties
Some drivers mistakenly believe that refusing a breath or blood test will protect them from being charged. However, under Massachusetts’ implied consent law, refusal brings automatic consequences, including:
- License suspension (180 days or more for first-time refusals)
- Use of the refusal in court as an indication of guilt
- Loss of eligibility for hardship licenses in certain cases
Officers can still arrest and charge you based on your behavior, driving patterns, and field test performance—even with no BAC data.
And remember: a refusal doesn’t erase the traffic stop. Everything observed during that encounter still counts.
Real-World Examples of Low-BAC OUI Arrests
Scenario 1: BAC 0.05% but Slurred Speech and Confusion
A driver has a BAC of 0.05%—below the legal limit. However, they are stopped for weaving between lanes and nearly hitting a curb. They fail two field sobriety tests, appear confused, and admit to drinking and taking anxiety medication. They are charged with OUI based on actual impairment.
Scenario 2: Commercial Driver with BAC of 0.04%
A commercial truck driver is stopped after rolling through a stop sign. Breath test shows 0.04%—which meets the per se limit for commercial drivers. The operator is disqualified from commercial driving privileges and cited under Massachusetts law for OUI.
Scenario 3: Underage Driver with BAC of 0.03%
A 19-year-old is pulled over for speeding. Breath test shows 0.03% BAC. The driver is arrested under the zero tolerance law for underage drivers and faces license suspension, enrollment in an alcohol education program, and possible court proceedings.
These examples reflect how BAC numbers alone do not tell the whole story. Context matters, and the law allows for flexibility in charging impaired drivers.
Consequences of an OUI Below the Legal Limit
An OUI charge—regardless of BAC—can lead to both criminal and administrative penalties:
- Criminal penalties: Fines, probation, potential jail time, alcohol education programs
- RMV actions: License suspension or revocation, reinstatement fees, possible ignition interlock requirement
- Permanent record: OUI convictions are not automatically expunged and stay on your RMV record for life
- Insurance impact: OUI triggers major increases in auto insurance premiums and possible policy cancellation
Even without a high BAC reading, the consequences are identical in many cases to those for drivers who test above the legal limit.
FAQ: Can You Get an OUI Below 0.08% in Massachusetts?
Can I be charged with OUI even if I pass the breath test?
Yes. If the officer observes signs of impairment, you can be arrested and charged with OUI regardless of your BAC.
Does Massachusetts law require a BAC of 0.08% for an OUI?
No. The law allows OUI charges for anyone whose ability to drive is impaired—even with a lower BAC.
Are field sobriety tests reliable evidence?
While not perfect, field sobriety tests are admissible in court and commonly used to establish impairment.
Can I refuse the breath test to avoid charges?
You can refuse, but it leads to immediate license suspension and does not prevent arrest or prosecution.
Do underage drivers face stricter BAC rules?
Yes. Massachusetts enforces a zero tolerance policy for drivers under 21, with a legal limit of just 0.02%.
Conclusion
In Massachusetts, the legal limit for BAC is not the only measure of impaired driving. A driver can—and often is—charged with OUI even when their BAC is below 0.08%. Police rely on field sobriety tests, driving behavior, and other observable signs of impairment to determine if someone is unsafe to drive.
This means that the “legal limit” is not a line of safety. Drivers who assume they are “good to go” because they’re under 0.08% may still face serious legal trouble. Understanding how Massachusetts law approaches impaired driving helps you make better choices and avoid long-term consequences.
To better understand how these BAC rules fit into the broader legal framework, read our guide on Blood Alcohol Content And Legal Limits.
For more context on how BAC is used under impaired driving laws, visit What Blood Alcohol Content (BAC) Means Under DUI Laws for additional clarity.