Have A Question? Search This Site:
Understanding DUI Arrests Without Breath Test Failure in Maryland
Many drivers in Maryland assume that failing a breathalyzer is the only way to get arrested for driving under the influence. However, that’s not the case. In Maryland, a driver can be arrested for DUI—or more specifically, for DWI (Driving While Impaired)—even if they don’t blow over the 0.08% blood alcohol concentration (BAC) legal limit or if no breath test is performed at all.
Law enforcement officers are trained to assess a variety of signs and behaviors that indicate impairment. These include erratic driving, physical indicators like slurred speech or unsteady movement, and poor performance on field sobriety tests. If an officer observes enough of these signs, they may determine there is probable cause for an arrest—regardless of breath test results.
Additionally, drivers who refuse to take a breath test may still be arrested based on officer observations and other evidence. Refusal also triggers its own penalties under Maryland’s implied consent laws.
This post breaks down how DUI arrests in Maryland can occur without a failed breath test, what officers rely on instead, and the broader legal framework that allows for such arrests. It’s important to understand that breath test results are just one piece of a larger picture that law enforcement considers during a DUI stop.
The Legal Standards for DUI vs DWI in Maryland
Maryland recognizes two main alcohol-related driving offenses: DUI (Driving Under the Influence) and DWI (Driving While Impaired). The distinction between the two is central to understanding how an arrest can happen even if you don’t fail a breath test.
A DUI in Maryland typically applies when a driver’s BAC is 0.08% or higher. This level meets the per se legal definition of intoxication and generally leads to a DUI charge. No further proof of impairment is necessary beyond the BAC result.
A DWI, on the other hand, applies when the driver’s BAC is between 0.04% and 0.07%, or when there is clear evidence of impairment regardless of BAC. Officers may use their observations—such as erratic driving or failing sobriety tests—to support a DWI charge even if the breath test result is below the legal limit or if no test is performed.
This two-tiered structure allows Maryland law enforcement to address a broader range of impaired driving behaviors. It means a driver could be legally arrested and charged with DWI without exceeding the legal BAC threshold or without any BAC result at all.
Officer Observations as Evidence of Impairment
In Maryland, one of the most important tools in determining impairment is an officer’s direct observations. During a traffic stop, police assess a driver’s behavior, physical appearance, and responses to questions. These assessments play a key role in deciding whether to initiate a DUI or DWI arrest—even in the absence of a failed breath test.
Officers look for the following signs:
- Slurred or slow speech
- Bloodshot eyes
- Strong odor of alcohol or drugs
- Unsteady movements or difficulty exiting the vehicle
- Confusion or inconsistent answers
- Inability to follow simple instructions
These observations are carefully documented in the officer’s report and can serve as probable cause for an arrest. The law in Maryland allows arrests based on a totality of the circumstances, which means a combination of factors—not just a single failed test—can justify taking someone into custody.
This process ensures that drivers who may be impaired, but who have not taken or failed a breath test, are still subject to enforcement. It also underscores the importance of how you present yourself during a stop, as officer assessments carry legal weight.
The Role of Field Sobriety Tests in DUI Arrests
Field sobriety tests are commonly used in Maryland to evaluate a driver’s level of impairment when a breath test is unavailable or inconclusive. These standardized tests are physical and cognitive tasks that assess balance, coordination, and the ability to follow directions.
Common tests include:
- Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) – Eye movement tracking
- Walk-and-Turn – Following a line heel-to-toe and turning as directed
- One-Leg Stand – Standing on one leg while counting aloud
Performance on these tests is observed and scored by the officer. Difficulty completing the tasks or failing to follow instructions can be taken as signs of impairment. Poor performance, especially when combined with other indicators, may lead to a DUI or DWI arrest even without a breath test result.
In Maryland, drivers are not legally required to perform field sobriety tests, but refusal may raise suspicion. Officers are allowed to factor in the refusal, along with other observations, when deciding whether to proceed with an arrest.
These tests play a vital role in DUI enforcement when no chemical test is available, and they are often cited in the arrest report and used later in administrative or court proceedings.
Refusing a Breath Test in Maryland: What It Means
Maryland has an implied consent law, which means that by driving on state roads, you automatically agree to submit to chemical testing (breath, blood, or urine) if lawfully requested by an officer. Refusing to take a breath test doesn’t protect you from arrest—it can actually lead to immediate penalties.
Here’s what happens if you refuse:
- Your license can be confiscated on the spot
- You’ll be issued a temporary paper license valid for 45 days
- Your license will be automatically suspended—typically 270 days for a first refusal
- Refusal can be used as evidence of guilt in court or administrative hearings
Even if you haven’t failed a test, the refusal itself can trigger consequences and increase the likelihood of arrest. Officers may rely on other forms of evidence—like field sobriety tests and behavioral signs—to justify taking you into custody.
In Maryland, refusing the test doesn’t prevent a DUI or DWI arrest. It simply shifts the focus to other forms of impairment assessment, and it brings its own penalties under the administrative rules of the Maryland Motor Vehicle Administration (MVA).
Arrests Based on Drug Impairment Without a Breath Test
Not all DUI arrests in Maryland are related to alcohol. Drivers can also be arrested for drug-related impairment, including both illegal drugs and prescription medications. In these cases, a breath test is either ineffective or irrelevant—since it doesn’t detect substances other than alcohol.
If an officer suspects drug impairment, they may call in a Drug Recognition Expert (DRE)—a specially trained officer who conducts a 12-step evaluation. This process looks at the driver’s behavior, vital signs, and other physical indicators to assess impairment. A urine or blood test may be used later to confirm drug presence.
Even without a positive drug test at the time of the stop, a driver may still be arrested based on the officer’s evaluation and other evidence. Maryland law does not require a specific chemical threshold for drug impairment—officer judgment plays a central role.
This is another way a DUI arrest can happen without failing a breath test. When drugs are involved, officers rely on field evaluations and expert analysis to make their case.
Administrative and Legal Consequences of Arrest Without a Test
Being arrested for DUI or DWI in Maryland without a failed breath test still triggers serious consequences. These can include:
- License suspension by the MVA
- Required alcohol or drug education programs
- Possible court charges depending on the evidence
- Increased insurance costs
Even in the absence of a chemical test, the administrative side of the legal process moves forward. A driver arrested based on officer observations or failed sobriety tests may receive a notice of license suspension and be required to request a hearing to challenge it.
The court system may also become involved if additional charges are filed. In Maryland, the arrest report, field test results, and officer testimony may be used as evidence in place of a breath test.
Drivers often underestimate the seriousness of being arrested without a test failure. The reality is that Maryland’s system is designed to capture a wide range of impaired driving behaviors—even when chemical evidence isn’t part of the picture.
FAQ: DUI Arrests Without Failing a Breath Test in Maryland
Can I be arrested for DUI in Maryland if I passed a breath test?
Yes. If the officer observes signs of impairment or if you fail field sobriety tests, you can still be arrested.
What’s the difference between DUI and DWI in Maryland?
DUI generally requires a BAC of 0.08% or higher, while DWI can be based on a lower BAC or officer observations of impairment.
Is it legal to refuse a breath test in Maryland?
You can refuse, but doing so will result in automatic license suspension and may be used against you in court.
Can I still lose my license without a failed breath test?
Yes. Maryland’s MVA can suspend your license based on an arrest, refusal, or officer testimony—even without chemical evidence.
Do I have to take field sobriety tests?
No, but refusal can be used as part of the officer’s reasoning for making an arrest.
What if I was using legal medication?
Legal drugs can still impair your ability to drive. If an officer determines you’re impaired, you can be arrested, even without alcohol involved.
Will a DUI arrest without a breath test appear on my record?
Yes. An arrest record and any administrative actions, like license suspension, will appear even without a test failure.
Conclusion
In Maryland, a DUI arrest can happen without a failed breath test. Officers rely on field sobriety tests, physical observations, and behavioral cues to assess impairment. Refusing a breath test or being suspected of drug use can also lead to arrest and legal consequences—even without a BAC reading.
For a full breakdown of the DUI process in Maryland, visit the How DUI Laws Work page. To understand the types of behaviors that often lead to arrests, explore What Triggers a DUI Arrest During a Traffic Stop.